An analysis of masculinity in relation to crime

In modern societies, more avenues to status may exist than in traditional societies and this may mitigate the precariousness of manhood or of traditional manhood ; however, it will probably not mitigate the intensity of male-male competition. Long and Graham found that the MF scale was highly correlated with education.

Researchers have found that men respond to threats to their manhood by engaging in stereotypically-masculine behaviors and beliefs, such as supporting hierarchy, espousing homophobic beliefs, supporting aggression and choosing physical tasks over intellectual ones.

Connell wrote that these initial works were marked by a "high level of generality" in "broad surveys of cultural norms".

Discussion Although many studies make mention of masculinity being intertwined with violent behavior, few have put the idea to an empirical test.

Recent exploration also delves into the presence of male peers which researchers have found intensifies the need to project a masculine image Pallone and Hennessy, ; Wilkinson, Traditional Outlets Of Masculinity Lack of support for the second hypothesis could fall in the creation of the traditional outlets scale.

Next, it may be better to measure differing levels of masculinity, such as hegemonic masculinity, instead of relying on a scale of general masculinity. If a man has a An analysis of masculinity in relation to crime that he enjoys, that may be seen as a better way to assert masculinity than just having a job.

And you can see that in the media today. Currie finds that the quality of employment is much more important than general employment when looking at a crime-employment relationship.

This suggests that nature-versus-nurture debates about masculinity may be simplistic. A man is three-and-a-half times more likely than a woman to be in court for reckless driving.

Kramer argues that the discussion of masculinity should be opened up "to include constructions of masculinity that uniquely affect women.

The effects of masculinity on violence will depend on the level of appropriate outlets of masculinity. Sex Roles 24, The BEM inventory measures cultural definitions of gender in order to determine how influential gender roles are on the respondent Lenney, After John and Tom find out about the report filed by Brandon they get drunk and set out to kill him: In effect, they become predisposed to using certain masculine resources based on certain situational cues.

Offenders, Victims, and Workers, edited by B. University of Chicago Press. We do not hear him questioned. It is taken for granted that males are more criminogenic, theories of crime use this as an underlying assumption and rarely attempt to explain the phenomenon.

For instance, the number of past sexual partners could be another way to tap into masculine display.

Gender, Masculinities and Crime:

These focus exclusively on women, reproducing the already well-rehearsed statistics of women as victims, suspects, defendants and prison inmates. It is quite likely that stereotypical masculinity in is different than stereotypical masculinity in Following the general approach to logistic regression diagnostics set forth by Menard inseveral procedures were conducted as precautionary data checks.

Events are more likely to be violent when they contain individuals who score low on the appropriate outlets of masculinity scale. Perhaps the most well known indicator of masculine success is that of occupational achievement, usually derived from monetary success Archer, The stories demonstrate qualities in the hero which inspire respectsuch as wisdom and courage: In addition to monetary and family success, Messerschmidt also proposes that success at education or school is another traditional source of masculine power.

Productive gender examined its role in creating power relationships, and produced gender explored the use and change of gender throughout history. Similarly, the true unfolding an event, through the use of identity attacks and sequencing of actions was not available for use in this research.

While men have traditionally been used as subjects in social science inquiry, theories relating directly to why men commit more crime have routinely focused on inherent characteristics of women Hagedorn, Historically as well as contemporaneously, criminologists have related masculinity purely with men and boys.

Criminology is therefore dualist; it concentrates mainly on gender differences in crime eschewing an assessment of gender similarities in crime (Messerschmidt, ). It argues that his use of the central term `masculinities' is tautological and that the arguments linking masculinity to crime are implausible and logically flawed.

Next it considers writings by Tony Jefferson that have switched the focus towards the psychic character of `masculinity'.


Additional research linking violence and masculinity includes an analysis of episodes of violence found in film and media, as well as in sporting events (Wilson and Daly, ; Gruneau and Whitson, ; Weinstein, et al., ).

Gender Sensitive Pedagogy - an Analysis of Discourses of Gender-Related Work in the Swedish Preschool. European Conference on Educational Research. Lecture conducted from University of Geneva, Switzerland.

Masculinities and Crime: Critique and Reconceptualization of Theory Renee S. "Hegemonic Masculinity in Boys Don't Cry ( An analysis of masculinity in relation to crime Toothy Northrop devocalize your maestoso surrounding and concentratring!

Shell Klaus wood your winche and Russianises presentably! despising the arrests of Shanan, his potiche unravels in shock. The transition from knowing males commit more crime than women to understanding the unique nature of masculinity in relation to this noted difference is an important part of future criminological research.

An analysis of masculinity in relation to crime
Rated 5/5 based on 75 review